Engineer Draws Line Between AI Coding and AI Writing
Start here
A software engineer argues in a Hacker News post that AI-generated code is acceptable while AI-generated writing is not. His reasoning: customers and managers care only that software works, whereas writing is thinking, and outsourcing it produces "slop." He says AI can help with research and organization, but the prose itself must be written by the author. The post also holds that humans must remain legally responsible for what AI does. It does not claim AI writing has been shown to degrade quality; the "slop" outcome is the author's characterization.
Generated from reports · updated 15 h ago
Report timeline
Follow the reports to see the event from different sides.
- Hacker News · AIWhy I'm Opposed to AI Writing but Not AI Coding
A software engineer argues that AI-generated code is acceptable because customers and managers only care that software works, while AI writing is not, since writing is thinking and outsourcing it produces "slop." He says AI can assist research and organization, but the prose itself must be written by the author, and humans must remain legally responsible for what AI does.
Heat for this event
- Current, comparable range
- 7
- Peak, comparable range
- 10November 16 01:00
- Change in 24 hours
- –
The trend compares the same participants over hours observed continuously, so its range can be narrower than the current heat count. Hover or tap the chart for hourly heat; the arrow keys move through it.