Skip to content
Hot eventDeveloping

DOJ Uses AI Detector Pangram to Accuse Defense of 'Defense by ChatGPT'

2 reports1 reporting sourcesUpdated 9 h ago

Start here

AI digest

Justice Department lawyers in a Texas voter fraud case ran the defense's filings through the AI detection service Pangram and cited the results in court, calling the defense "defense by ChatGPT" and the motions "AI slop" that wastes judicial resources, according to court filings reviewed by 404 Media. The case is in federal court in the Northern District of Texas, which recently began requiring attorneys to disclose generative AI use in filings. The Pangram results were mixed and did not show the briefs were fully AI-drafted, but government attorneys wrote that they did not feel they should have to respond substantively to briefs that were partly AI-generated. Defense attorney Mario Herrera said he used AI tools to prepare a federal jury trial in four days after lead attorney Nicole Knox had a medical emergency. Judge Mark Pittman criticized the defense's AI use, while Herrera argued detection software cannot determine who wrote a document or whether its law is correct.

Generated from reports · updated 8 h ago

Report timeline

Follow the reports to see the event from different sides.

November 17
  1. 404 Media
    DOJ lawyers use AI detector Pangram to accuse defense attorneys of 'defense by ChatGPT'

    Lawyers for the Department of Justice are using the AI writing detection service Pangram to argue that opposing attorneys used AI to draft legal arguments, according to court filings reviewed by 404 Media. In a high-profile voter fraud case, government attorneys wrote that the case had turned into 'defense by ChatGPT' and described the motions as 'AI slop' that wastes judicial resources. The filings show attorneys on both sides trying to catch each other using AI and citing that claim in arguments to the court.

  2. 404 Media
    DOJ Uses AI Detector Pangram Against Defense Attorneys in Texas Voter Fraud Case

    Justice Department lawyers ran defense filings in a Texas voter fraud case through the AI detection service Pangram and cited the results in court, calling the defense "defense by ChatGPT." The Pangram results were mixed and did not show the briefs were fully AI-drafted, and defense attorney Mario Herrera said he used AI tools to prepare a federal jury trial in four days after lead attorney Nicole Knox had a medical emergency. Judge Mark Pittman criticized the defense's AI use, while Herrera argued detection software cannot determine who wrote a document or whether its law is correct.

Heat for this event

Current, comparable range
8
Peak, comparable range
10November 18 00:00
Change in 24 hours
–

The trend compares the same participants over hours observed continuously, so its range can be narrower than the current heat count. Hover or tap the chart for hourly heat; the arrow keys move through it.