Thomas Nagel Calls AI Consciousness Claims 'Just Ridiculous'
Start here
Philosopher Thomas Nagel, winner of this week's $1 million Berggruen Prize, said treating large language models as possibly conscious is "just ridiculous," arguing they produce only language and lack any nervous-system-like substrate. The 89-year-old NYU professor emeritus also called Anthropic's work on Claude's "model welfare" criminal, warning that users will wrongly believe such systems are conscious. Nagel's remarks target a debate over whether AI systems could have morally relevant inner states; Anthropic's model-welfare effort treats Claude's possible experience as something to consider. Nagel's objection rests on the absence of a biological substrate, not on tests of AI behavior.
Generated from reports · updated 34 min ago
Report timeline
Follow the reports to see the event from different sides.
- Hacker News · AIPhilosopher Thomas Nagel Takes On AI Consciousness: 'Just Ridiculous'
Philosopher Thomas Nagel, who won this week's $1 million Berggruen Prize, said treating large language models as possibly conscious is "just ridiculous" because they produce only language and lack any nervous-system-like substrate. The 89-year-old NYU professor emeritus also called Anthropic's work on Claude's "model welfare" criminal, warning that users will wrongly believe such systems are conscious.
Heat for this event
Not enough continuous observations yet to draw a trend.