Skip to content
Hacker News · AI·· 18 h agoAI score58

UK Court of Appeal Condemns Police Officer's Use of Microsoft Copilot to Draft Victim Impact Statement

AI-generated victim impact statements condemned by the Court of Appeal

AI summary

The UK Court of Appeal condemned a police officer's use of Microsoft Copilot to generate a victim personal statement aimed at maximizing emotional impact and securing a higher sentencing category, in R v Jerome Gibson [2026] EWCA Crim 1302. The court said no police officer should ever prepare a witness statement this way and no such statement should be relied on in a criminal case, though the appeal failed because the sentencing judge used only facts the victim had genuinely recounted. The judgment adds that AI-generated submissions often run long, cite summarized or hallucinated authorities, and notes some coroners have already issued directions regulating AI use in court filings.

Source:Hacker News · AI · ukpolicelawblog.com